top of page

Responsible Tourism in the Arctic: Beyond the Sustainability Label

Nov 10
4 min read

Looking Beyond the Sustainability Label


Sustainability has become one of the most frequently used words in the travel industry. It appears in brochures, websites and descriptions of almost every kind of holiday. Yet the word itself tells us relatively little about what a company actually does.

When considering expedition travel in the Arctic, we believe the more useful question is what happens when an operator enters a remote region. A vessel arrives, visitors come ashore and communities open their homes and surroundings to people from elsewhere. Even when visits are carefully organised, tourism is an intrusion into somebody else's environment and daily life. The important question is how that presence is managed and what it contributes in return.


Adventure Canada prefers to discuss responsible tourism rather than rely on broad sustainability claims. During our conversation with the company, its emphasis on relationships with local communities, cultural educators and artisans stood out. These are not occasional additions to an itinerary, but central elements of the way the company approaches its expeditions.


This does not mean that every environmental challenge has been solved. It means looking at the specific decisions an operator makes and assessing them honestly.


Masked guide in traditional fur parka leads a small blue-jacketed group on a windy coastal hill above icy sea and mountains.
Visiting local communities is part of sustainable travel when done right, like Adventure Canada does 1

Giving Something Back to the Communities We Visit


One of the most meaningful aspects of Adventure Canada's approach is its work with local communities. The company maintains communication with communities before visits, respects requests about whether and how guests may come ashore, and works with local people to organise activities.


The employment of Inuit cultural educators is particularly important. They contribute as members of the expedition team, sharing knowledge and perspectives throughout the journey. Local artisans can also sell their work to visitors, creating opportunities for income through their skills and creativity.


There are also more direct community initiatives. On one Northwest Passage voyage, an onboard auction raised CAD $29,000 for a youth climbing-wall project in Pond Inlet. The funds were directed towards a specific local project rather than an unspecified charitable cause.


Outdoor Inuit dance performance by the sea, with one man leaping high as another watches and an audience sits on wooden steps.
Games by the local community at Pond Inlet 2

For us, this is an important distinction. Responsible tourism should not treat communities as attractions or assume that visitors automatically know what is best for them. It should begin with listening, respecting local priorities and creating opportunities that communities themselves welcome.


The number of visitors, the way excursions are organised and the economic opportunities created all matter. We have seen in European cities how tourism can become damaging when visitor numbers and commercial interests grow beyond what local communities can comfortably accommodate. The Arctic's remoteness does not automatically protect it from similar pressures.


The Environmental Footprint: An Honest Conversation


Expedition cruising inevitably has an environmental footprint. Ships consume fuel, produce emissions and operate in some of the world's most sensitive environments. Measures such as reducing red-meat consumption, using local ingredients where available and employing dynamic positioning to avoid anchoring in certain sensitive seabed areas can make a difference, but they do not eliminate the impact of operating a vessel.


Our conversations with scientists have also made us think more carefully about this balance. Dr Alessandro Silvano, whose research concerns the ocean and climate, has discussed the opportunities that expedition vessels can provide for scientific work in remote regions. A ship can bring researchers and equipment to locations that would otherwise be extremely difficult or expensive to reach. It can also create opportunities for travellers to learn about research and environmental change directly from the people studying them.


There is an important tension here. The vessel that makes this research possible also has an environmental cost. We should acknowledge both realities rather than use the scientific value of an expedition as a justification for overlooking its footprint.


The optional Adventure Canada's carbon-offset programme can be one way for travellers to address part of their emissions, but offsetting is not the same as preventing emissions in the first place. It should be considered alongside the operator's actual environmental practices, not as a substitute for them. Adventure Canada's Carbon offset program supports the Great Bear Forest Carbon Project.


An introduction to the Great Bear Forest Carbon Project

The Responsibility of the Traveller


Responsible travel does not rest with the expedition operator alone. Travellers also make choices that influence the places they visit.


This begins with how we behave in communities: asking permission before taking photographs, respecting local guidance, listening rather than assuming, and understanding that a destination is somebody else's home rather than simply a place to be experienced.


It also means being willing to learn about the environmental changes taking place. On an expedition, climate change is not just an abstract subject discussed in a presentation. Travellers can see changing landscapes, observe wildlife and speak with scientists and cultural educators who explain what is happening and why it matters.

That experience can have a lasting effect. A vessel does not change the global climate on its own, but a journey can change how people understand the world and the decisions they make afterwards. We see that educational value as an important part of responsible expedition travel, provided it is accompanied by an honest understanding of the journey's own impact.


At Sarasota Cruise Agency, our own work on Arctic research and conversations with scientists has also led us to consider how we can take greater responsibility. We are developing a carbon-offset programme for our company so that clients will have an opportunity to contribute to addressing the footprint of their travel.


Further Reading


Ask More of Your Expedition


When comparing expedition operators, we encourage travellers to look beyond sustainability labels and ask specific questions. How does a company work with local communities? What opportunities does it create for local people? How does it manage its environmental impact, and what does it communicate openly about the limitations of its efforts?


At Sarasota Cruise Agency, we want our clients to understand not only where they are travelling, but also what their journey means for the places they visit. Responsible travel begins with informed choices, respect and a willingness to recognise both the value and the consequences of exploring the world.


  1. Photo by Dennis Minty

  2. Photo by Jen Derbach

Comments


bottom of page